3/30 Ups & Downs

The campaign season is heating up, and some candidates have shone as others start to fall behind. Here’s who had a good week, and who didn’t.

Kathleen Kane. Seeing the words “President,” and “endorses,” in a subject heading certainly gets a reporter’s attention, like this week when former President Bill Clinton backed the Attorney General hopeful. Kane and the Clintons have long been close, so it wasn’t a shocker. But it certainly was a strong response to Patrick Murphy’s long list of endorsements. And Kane started to flex her financial muscle a bit too, with her introductory TV ad getting fairly strong play in most of the state.

Sam Rohrer. He’s had a huge week. At the Pa. Leadership Conference, he ran away with the straw poll of the U.S. Senate primary. He picked up the backing of two national figures, Herman Cain and Michele Bachmann. But the flip side: two polls in a row (F&M, Wenzel/CU) have shown him losing ground to Tom Smith. Without a change in his financial situation, he faces a tough challenge reaching voters outside his devoted base of supporters and keeping up as paid media starts.

Jason Altmire. The Congressman is in the catbird seat. He can spend more of his cash defining Mark Critz than vice versa, since much of the new district is already his and Mark Critz needs to raise his name ID. In an effective if not intellectually honest ad this week, Almtire lands a strong hit on Critz. Regarding legitimate complains that the ad takes Critz’s vote out of context, Turnabout is fair play. Altmire has taken his share of lumps for deviating from the Democratic party line. In this case, Critz’s adherence to the party line has exposed him to criticism. And let’s face it: it’s politics, not a truth-telling contest. Also he can now say – for the first time – he’s been endorsed by labor unions, plural, because a second one backed him Thursday.

Equality PA & Liberty City Dems. Two of the preeminent LGBT rights groups in the state endorsed openly gay attorney and LGBT advocate Brian Sims for state House. In most cases, no big deal. But not in this race. Sims is challenging Rep. Babette Josephs, one of the most reliable and most vocal supporters that the LGBT community has in Harrisburg. One can fully appreciate the desire of these groups to see the first openly gay Pa. legislator, but voting records count, and so should loyalty.

Babette Josephs. Proponents of the controversial ultrasound mandate were on their heels and retreating. The vote had been cancelled, and co-sponsors were dropping like flies. But Josephs surrendered the rhetorical high ground this week with her suggestion that women who supported the bill – like chief sponsor Rep. Kathy Rapp – are “men with breasts.” It soured an otherwise sweet victory by women’s rights groups.

Arlen Specter. What can we say? The man knows how to make news. This week, the former Senator made a big splash with his remark that Mitt Romney, “has changed positions more often than a pornographic movie queen.” Classic Arlen. And so close to the day that his new book ‘Life Among the Cannibals’ hit stores. Coincidence?

March 30th, 2012 | Posted in Features, Front Page Stories, Top Stories | 9 Comments

9 thoughts on “3/30 Ups & Downs”

  1. SoPhi says:

    I’ve heard Sims say several times that he is more fit to work with republicans in the state. Either Sims is naive, doesn’t understand the current culture in Harrisburg or will be willing to bend to the right. Harrisburg is currently run by dangerous extremists, its alarms me that he thinks he can work with them.

  2. Babette Josephs is ineffectual and offers no leadership of any kind. Brian Sims, it seems, would reliably support a Progressive agenda and could not be worse than Rep. Josephs and her gratuitously insulting remarks about those with whom she disagrees.

    As an aside, it will be entertaining to see how Rep. Metcalfe reacts to openly Gay legislator.
    Mr. Sims would be, I think, the first openly Gay legislator.

    On the other hand, the Gay community is not as fiscally reckless as Babette Josephs and her wealthy, center city liberal allies. Who knows, the openly Gay legislator may find common ground with rural legislators of both parties on some fiscal issues.

    It really is time for Rep. Josephs to move on. She will have very, very soft landing in retirement.

  3. When you throw someone over as that community wants to do for one of their own, they will have less of a chance to work with the GOP than they do now. Bad tactical mistake, they should have just stayed neutral. And who will sims really be representing? Whoever said this is the most progressive district in the state obviously does not know the lines.

  4. Justin says:

    You’re absolutely right, David. Neither Liberty City or Equality Pennsylvania were saying that Babette is bad, just that Brian is better poised to work with other legislators and get bills passed. ANYONE who has holds the 182nd district will have the exact same voting record as Babette! It’s the most liberal/progressive district in the state! Babette is toxic to other legislators who simply won’t work with her.

    Brian will actually work with other legislators to pass bills of his own, something Babette has NEVER done.

  5. David Diano says:

    The biggest complaint I hear (consistently) about Rep. Babette Josephs from my friends in the 8th ward and around city is that she really doesn’t do very much at all. Lazy legislator who punts on important legislation. It’s time for some fresh blood.

    Just because she as been a vocal supporter, doesn’t mean that you can’t get a more vocal supporter who does more than just talk, but gets things done.

  6. Alex Hamilton says:

    Rohrere has money problems? I guess he should have voted himself a bigger pay raise!

  7. SoPhi says:

    “voting records count, and so should loyalty.”

    AMEN

  8. TNardi says:

    Disclosure, I suppose. I’m a member of Liberty City Democrats.

  9. TNardi says:

    So we’re making value judgments on which candidates organizations should be endorsing now?

Comments are closed.