Altmire, Critz Vote for Holder Contempt

Both Altmire and Critz broke with their party, possibly in exchange from an NRA endorsement.

With a possible endorsement from the National Rifle Association on the line, Reps. Mark Critz (D-Cambria) and Jason Altmire (D-Allegheny) broke with their party to vote in favor of holding U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder in contempt of Congress for his failure to release information regarding the Fast and Furious scandal.

Critz and Altmire, who represent districts with large numbers of NRA members, voted in favor of contempt for Holder after the NRA said it was scoring the vote, making it more likely that they would receive the organization’s endorsement in future elections.

In Critz’s case, the endorsement could come as a boost for his re-election campaign against Republican challenger Keith Rothfus. For Altmire, whose district was absorbed into Critz’s during redistricting, the NRA endorsement could be useful in a future campaign.

In a campaign press release, Critz denounced the handling of the investigation by House Republicans, but nonetheless supported turning over reports of what he called “federal law enforcement misconduct.”

“At the end of the day, Congress has the responsibility to provide effective oversight of government programs and taxpayer funds, and it’s time to put this issue behind us and focus on what the American people really care about – creating jobs and strengthening our economy,” Critz.

For Altmire, the vote to hold Holder in contempt of Congress was a matter of consistency — Altmire originally supported a similar resolution in 2008.

“I believe it would be inconsistent for me to vote against today’s resolution simply because the political tables are now turned,” Altmire said.  “I continue to believe that Congress has investigative authority and it is clear that the administration did not provide the requested documents.”

During an interview with Fox News, Holder dismissed the contempt charge as an attempt by House Republicans to score political points against the Obama Administration.

“Today’s vote is the regrettable culmination of what became a misguided — and politically motivated — investigation during an election year,” Holder said.  “By advancing it over the past year and a half, Congressman Issa and others have focused on politics over public safety.”

Holder denied knowledge of the sale of weapons to drug cartel members, saying that he disapproved of the method employed by the ATF and deemed Fast and Furious a failed operation.  House Republicans remained skeptical, and demanded he turn over 7,000 pages of documents regarding the case. Holder refused, leading to the contempt vote.

The NRA’s involvement case arose after Congress obtained documents stating ATF members called for a system that would have alerted authorities when more than three weapons were purchased from gun shops near the Mexican border. NRA officials allege the scandal is a government conspiracy designed to strengthen the argument for tighter gun-control laws.

Aside from Critz and Altmire, House members from Pennsylvania voted along partisan lines. Chakkah Fattah (D-Phila) joined other House Democrats by refusing to participate in the vote.

9 Responses

  1. Is there any way to eliminate this district completely and lose both the Dem and Rep morons that the morons in the district would elect?

  2. Altmire & Critz, gutless wonders. I’m done voting for Dems that are so gutless. My choice of votes in western PA are between stupid Republicans and gutless Dems. This seems to be a national phenomenon. A Republican with any sense and a courageous Dem is a rare find these days. Until this changes we will be stuck with a Congress full dim wits for sale and wusses saying please, please, please vote for me, pleeease. Obama can only do so much trying to work with these fools!!!

  3. The reason why Dems have low voter turnout is because there are no real Dems in any races in Southwest PA. Plenty of Progressives here. Just not showing up to the polls. A New Democratic Order is needed. Prepare for Revolution.

  4. again, the Congressmen are representing the prevailing views of their respective constituencies rather than playing games to serve party leadership. Dog hunting progressives lost Dem Dahlkemper with the same slavish adherence to philistine politics… thanks to their juvenile obama worship, they are rewarded with Mike Kelly as we are forced to witness yet another parade of inept Dem candidates bashing the sitting Congressman in the 3rd. You folks are phenomenally insipid.

  5. Blue dog hunter… liberal democrats would not do well in the southwest. Not the brand there.

  6. Both Altmire and Critz are snakes and they need to be purged from the Democratic Party. We got rid of Altmire and if Critz survives the general then its time to primary him in 2014. If they want to act like Republicans then they need to sign-up for the GOP. Democrats need to stick together against Republican-obstruction of the country; instead we have Blue-Dogs like Altimire and Critz acting like crabs in a barrel. They disgust me.

  7. Critz rejected his invitation to the Democratic Presidential Convention in Charlotte. He and Altmire are not acting the way that we observe because they oppose Obama, but rather due to the nature of the Republican-trending 12th CD. It is surprisingly like West Virginia, where Governor Earl Tomblin, Senator Joe Manchin, and US Rep Nick Rahall likewise decline their convention invitations.

  8. Unbelievable that the NRA has such a hold over Congress. If they’re not voting to please the NRA, they’re voting to please Grover Norquist, or any other monied interest group. It’s no wonder the entire country is fed up with Congress.

Comments are closed.

  • Who Will Be Speaker of the PA House on February 28?

    • Joanna McClinton (68%)
    • Mark Rozzi (27%)
    • A Republican TBD (5%)

    Total Voters: 315

    Loading ... Loading ...
Continue to Browser


To install tap and choose
Add to Home Screen