Best and Worst Ads of the 2012 Primary?

What were the TV ads that made the difference? Which ones fell flat? How about mailers, radio spots, and other campaign tools? Now that the primary is over, PoliticsPA wants to know: which campaigns stood out?

Submit your recommendation by contacting us here. Please include links whenever possible. Your response will be anonymous.

We’re interested in what you thought in these categories, and any others you think of:

Best TV ad, overall

Worst TV ad, overall

Best positive ad

Best negative/contrast ad

Best third party ad (PAC or Super PAC)

Best TV ad for a local campaign (state Rep or Senate)

Best web video

Best radio ad

Worst radio ad

Best direct mail piece

Worst direct mail piece

April 25th, 2012 | Posted in Features, Front Page Stories, Top Stories | 7 Comments

7 thoughts on “Best and Worst Ads of the 2012 Primary?”

  1. Wee Willie Weber says:

    Bill J. said “This woman in nuts, and her ad is terrible.” I am laughing so hard I have tears streaming down my face. What the hell was that? Zoro music playing in the background? Hahahahaha! No wonder she went down in flames. Nuts is an understatement.

  2. Judy brown says:

    I should add that the poll card merely reflects the character of Murphy who hid his liberalism from the voter and lied about his challenger and also the character of the PAGOP leadership.

  3. Judy brown says:

    The poll card issued by the PAGOP listed Welch, Freed, Maher and Vaughan who were endorsed by State Committee. Murphy was never endorsed but at the bottom of the card is says “Endorsed Republicans.” Cheap and dirty and as a member of State Committee I found it disgusting that they would lie to the electorate.

  4. Jerry Green says:

    Everything Joe Trippi did for Holden. His ads are low quality and crap.

  5. Bill J says:

    I would like to nominate the Babette Josephs ad for worst ad, This woman in nuts, and her ad is terrible.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MyucqtDFnEQ

  6. A A Jane says:

    I liked Dave Scholnick’s positive ad for state rep Babette Josephs.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MyucqtDFnEQ

  7. Jeanne Clark says:

    Nomination for Best Poll Card

    Allegheny County Democratic Committee. Not only listed endorsements, as usual; it also warned Democratic voters about Voter ID — Don’t let the Republicans steal your vote in November — and gave info about how to comply with the provision in November, and how voters could take action against the provision.

Comments are closed.