Close this search box.

Breaking Through: Will a Female or Minority Win Statewide Office?

In the long history of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, the hallways of Harrisburg have been dotted with elected statewide officials who are primarily white and male.

While the state’s largest cities have elected black mayors – three in Philadelphia (Wilson Goode, John Street, Michael Nutter) and one (Ed Gainey) in Pittsburgh –  the offices of governor, lieutenant governor, and U.S. senator have been primarily held by white males, with the exception of lieutenant governor Catherine Baker Knoll (2003-08), while only five blacks have served in the U.S. House from Pennsylvania.

The Keystone State is becoming an outlier. There are currently 57 Black U.S. House members – the most ever including Dwight Evans (D-Philadelphia). Black women are mayors of seven of the 100 most-populous cities (Chicago, Charlotte, San Francisco, Washington DC, New Orleans, St. Louis and Durham), while three Black candidates were among the primary contestants for Virginia governor a year ago, while three more are currently competing in the Maryland Democratic gubernatorial primary.

There has been some progress, as Stacy Garrity and Tim DeFoor won statewide office for treasurer and auditor, respectively, in 2020.

In Pennsylvania, there is one Black candidate for governor – Nche Zama – and one for lieutenant governor – Austin Davis. For the open Senate seat, there are two candidates – Malcolm Kenyatta on the Democratic side and Kathy Barnette for the GOP.

Why does it matter? Democrats rely on Black voters as a lifeline for the party, but Black candidates are still plagued with electability questions.

“We need to start interrogating why this question is almost only asked to candidates of color, women, marginalized candidates,” Kenyatta said in an interview. “Why are the only campaigns we take seriously are the campaigns that are run a certain type of way by the same type of people over and over again?”

Kenyatta and Barnette certainly stand out in a field of predominantly white, male millionaires.

“The unfair questions Malcolm was getting about money and viability early on came from establishment types not wanting to say out loud that they’re afraid Malcolm is too young, too Black or too gay to win statewide,” said Brendan McPhillips, who ran Joe Biden’s presidential campaign in Pennsylvania. 

Kenyatta tries to turn his identity into a positive, often saying in campaign speeches: “Do you want someone who says, ‘Vote for me because you have no choice’? Or, ‘Vote for me because I understand your life’?”

Barnette, in a 2020 TV interview, said she used to be a Democrat, and she “bought into the same lie as everyone else, that if you’re black, you must be a Democrat. Those living in predominantly black communities do not need to be told their issues. They are living them every day. What we need is to be empowered to resolve them – and that starts with giving the black community access to influence the world in which we live.”

The Republican Party touts that it has over 40 Black candidates running in GOP primaries for local and federal office. 

In the race for the newly-drawn 12th District, Summer Lee (D-34/Allegheny) is looking to become the first woman to hold a Senate seat from Pennsylvania.

She made history in 2018 when she won a state House race in southwest PA by beating 20-year incumbent Paul Costa. Even with that, she still combats doubts about her electability.

“It absolutely comes from within the party and from without,” Lee said. “The policies that we lift up are things that bring in more people and engage our base in different ways.”

“If there’s an opportunity for an African American to be a Democratic nominee, I believe they are uniquely positioned to bring along Democrats, Republicans and independents alike,” Antjuan Seawright, a Democratic strategist who’s worked with several campaigns, told Axios.

updated 2:05 p.m.

15 Responses

  1. We have women and minorities on the courts who ran and won statewide office. Kathleen Kane won statewide office for Attorney General.

    DUH !!!!

  2. James Jones of Hatboro is running for Lt. Governor. He is another Black Republican omitted from this article.

  3. Barbara Hager did not run
    “Closely” to Bob Casey for Governor.
    She holds the title for worse loss in statewide race,

    1. No mention of Barbara Hafer who served 8 years in State Treasurers Office, Her name is not even mentioned? Actually, this article misses the point completely and blames Pa for something it’s done right. Between Hafer and Knoll you have 20 years of statewide success. Then you can add on others and it paints the picture of open mindedness for PA.

  4. Does anyone own a google machine? “Breakthrough” the glass ceiling? Let’s see PA has had Barbara Hafer as a Republican State Treasurer for two terms and ran closely to Gov Casey in his second term when she had the R nomination for Gov. Then we had Catherine Baker Knoll who served multiple terms as State Treasurer. State Treasurer Knoll later became Lt Governor under Gov Ed Rendell.

  5. And there’s Melissa Hart. Former PA state senator and Congresswoman, current Republican candidate for Governor. Just trying to help you fill in gaps here…

  6. What about Kathleen Kane? Cause that worked out so well.

    The big irony is that the only reason anyone has ever heard of Malcolm Kenyatta is because he is black and gay. He’s never done anything! His entire case for voting for him is because of what he is, but he can’t cite anything he’s actually accomplished.

    When they keep putting forth horrible, unlikable candidates like Katy McGinty and Nina Ahmad, it’s no surprise a women can’t win..

    PA voted for Obama twice for POTUS, but I guess that doesn’t count because it’s just for President.

  7. Roxanne Jones and Shirley Kitchen were both African American females elected to the state senate. Summer Lee would not be the first. Do basic research.

  8. Chris Frye is Black Republican running for Lieutenant Governor, but he was left out of the article.

  9. the offices of governor, lieutenant governor, and U.S. senator have been solely held by white males,

    This must be news to the late Katherine Baker Knoll’s family. Do some research Steve.

    1. Stacy Garrity is a women, and elected statewide. But she’s a Republican, so maybe that is wrong kind of woman?

  • Reader Poll: Should President Joe Biden Step Aside?

    • Yes. He should step aside because of his age, declining ability to do the job. (45%)
    • No. He should not step aside. (39%)
    • Yes. He should step aside because he can't beat Donald Trump. (15%)

    Total Voters: 231

    Loading ... Loading ...
Continue to Browser


To install tap and choose
Add to Home Screen