Politically Uncorrected: Corbett’s Chancy Re-election Chance

Pennsylvania governor Tom Corbett expresses himself clearly on the subject: he has “no plans to break” Pennsylvania’s vaunted “tradition” of reelecting incumbent governors to a second term.  Translation, should one be needed: the governor is a candidate for reelection—and he plans to be reelected.

Others apparently are not so sure, notably the numerous wannabe Democratic opponents rumored or actually already running against him. They all sound pretty sure Governor Corbett’s destined for early retirement. 

Someone has to be wrong here and if we wait until November 2014, we will discover who.

But for those of a less patient bent, we posit the compelling arguments you will hear over the next two years: 1) why Tom Corbett will invariably be defeated for reelection and 2) the equally persuasive reasons why he invariably will win reelection.


Unpopularity – Corbett enters the race as the weakest incumbent for reelection in modern times. His positive job approval rating recently broke above 40 % (barely), thanks to good marks for his handling of Hurricane Sandy’s relief efforts. More typically he has been receiving approval ratings in the mid 30’s, a polling score rarely seen except among the most unpopular (and endangered) of incumbents.

Controversial Decisions – Much of Corbett’s unpopularity stems from his controversial budget cuts, especially to educational programs as well as the ongoing debate over how he handled the Sandusky sex abuse case .The bad news, however, is his low performance standings will be hard to reverse amid continuity fiscal austerity.  Indeed further unpopular decisions are likely in upcoming budget cycles as urgent challenges in pension reform, infrastructure development and social programs continue.

Ideological bent – Corbett remains an ideological warrior committed to less government, alternatives to public education and no new taxes. Inconveniently for him, Pennsylvania remains a state not comfortable with political ideologues, either on the right or left. Corbett’s hard opposition to tax increases, for example, has painted him into a corner in a state increasingly desperate to find new revenues.

Political Skills – While a very successful attorney general, Corbett’s tenure in the governor’s office has revealed a paucity of those political skills usually found in gubernatorial incumbents. Some blame his political leadership for the Republican Party’s poor statewide showing in November’s election. Worse perhaps he has failed to move virtually any of his major agenda, despite having large majorities of his own party in the state legislature. Relatedly he has failed to sell most of his proposals to voters and at times seemed little interested in doing so.


Yes, But – Corbett’s problems are seriously exaggerated. Yes he has encountered some political headwinds as have most incumbent governors combating economic hard times. Moreover as an incumbent he still commands impressive organizational, financial and political resources supporting his re-election. And while his polls have been underwhelming through most of his tenure, they are showing modest improvement as he enters his third year in office. For Corbett the worst is over.

We Have Seen this Movie Before – Corbett is not the first incumbent to look like a road kill early in his first term. In the 1990’s Republican Tom Ridge looked like a goner into his second year in office. By the spring of 1996, Ridge’s job performance dropped into the mid 40’s. Ten years later Democrat Ed Rendell reprised Ridge’s problems. In February of 2006 his job performance was just a nudge above 40%. Yet both won easily: Ridge by 26 points and Rendell by 21 points.

Somebody beats nobody every time – It’s a hoary, old political axiom: you can’t beat somebody with nobody. Right now Corbett, his problems notwithstanding, is a known quantity running against a field of relative unknowns.  Only one of Corbett’s putative opponents has run and won a statewide general election. None approach Corbett’s statewide name recognition. Historically this is a familiar pattern. With one possible exception the out party has not produced a viable gubernatorial opponent since 1970.

The Six Year Itch – It’s almost never good to be a candidate from the president’s party in the presidents sixth year in office.  Known as the six year itch the president’s party in that sixth year almost always courts electoral disaster–losing seats in Congress, governorships and state legislatures. In 2014, it is the Democrats doing the scratching making it doubly tough for any Democrat to take on and beat an incumbent. In addition to this powerful trend, Pennsylvanians tend to reelect governors from the party out of power in Washington.

Barring an actual tie on Election Day, these diametrically opposed arguments both can’t be correct. Corbett is going to win reelection or he isn’t. But it may matter less what either Corbett or his opponents do–and more what the economy does or does not. The only incumbent governor in modern times to almost lose–Dick Thornburgh in 1982–was the near victim of what was then the worst economy since World War II. Conversely those incumbent governors experiencing easy reelections all benefited from running in a year in which the economy was strong or on the mend. Almost inevitably, Corbett’s fate is hostage to what happens in the economy during the next two years.

13 Responses

  1. Corbett might have had a chance if he put anyone with reasonable experience in those “free” highly paid political appointed positions. But the incompetents he appointed have guaranteed many life-long repubs from central PA will vote democrat this year.

  2. A negative approval rating won’t amount to a hill of beans if the economy is doing well in the months leading up to the election. If people have jobs and have more money to spend Mr. Corbett will be around for 4 more years.

  3. I’d very much like to see a moderate Repubkican jump into the primary against Corbett. If there were Lunch Pail Republican willing to

  4. I would definitely vote for Castor. Corbetts is a disaster. He is cutting high demand services such as higher education in a time when you should not be. Yet, he will not tax these gas companies that are making money hand over fist at taxpayers expense. We are the only state that has not tax on these companies at all. It is disgrace. Time for Tommy boy to go.

  5. let not forget terry madonna like dick morris, and karl rove. spent the whole spring and summer telling every tv camera in the state the president would never win re-election, romney had this magical suburban appeal that never materialized and welch would win the gop primary for senate, . yes corbett is vunerable thats obvious. but to assume an outcome two years in advance is just stupid

  6. Another fine piece by Madonna and Young… BUT… when Rendell and Ridge seemed to be heading towards early electoral defeat, were the negatives worse for Rendell and Ridge than Corbett?

  7. Every election is relative. If the GOP primary opponent is Lynn Swann, or if the general election opponent is a Philly-area hack, Corbett wins. People inclined to vote AGAINST someone still need a good reason to vote FOR the opponent.

  8. Corbett will win re-election as no possible candidate will risk the loss against an incumbant meaning the top tier will wait till 2018 when it is an open seat.
    At which point it is highly possible that LG Cawley could be the first to defeat the back and forth of the office. He is a far better campaigner and politico than Corbett wishes he could be.

  9. Well… there are a couple things here…. First, excellent article by Madonna and Young. Madonna is a great politico who inspires many young Pennsylvanian’s. Second, it takes three things to get elected Message, Money and Mobility. Mobility is essentially turnout. Corbett will probably win on money but that is it. Turnout in PA in a non-presidential year is disputable for both parties. Corbett’s message will not resonate with moderates and liberals.

    To make a long story short, Corbett is the most vulnerable incumbent Gov in modern history and I think he will lose. He is too radical.

  10. WHAT EVER I CAN DO IN MY POWER TO GET CORBITT OUT OF THE CAPITOL I WILL DO >>>>> he is for the ritch and famous and i don’t believe in that >>>> >>>>>>>>>>GET>>> RID >>>> OF >>>>> HIM

  11. Republican must find someone alternate to Tom Corbett and Democratic should choose a good candidate and both candidate must be Washington outsider

Comments are closed.

  • When Should The Special Elections For The PA House Be Held?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...
Continue to Browser


To install tap and choose
Add to Home Screen