Dem Poll: Perry Leads Scott 44-43

A close one or just another internal poll?

PennLive released an exclusive poll this morning showing Democratic candidate for the 10th Congressional district, George Scott trailing by 1 point to incumbent Rep. Scott Perry (R-York). An outside group supporting the Democratic candidate conducted the polling.  

The Public Policy Polling telephone survey of 650 voters shows Perry leading Scott 44-43, while 12% remain undecided. The poll was conducted on Sept 24-25. PPP self-identifies as a liberal pollster, although their track record is fairly close to center. Their results tilt Democrats’ way by an average of 0.3%, according to analysts at FiveThirtyEight, which gives PPP a B rating.

That said, all internal poll results should be taken with a grain of salt – especially one with unclear provenance.

The Republican-leaning district went for President Donald Trump by nearly 10 points in the 2016 election. Asked who the voted for in 2016, the survey’s respondents said they went for Trump over Clinton 50 to 41.

The candidates have nearly identical favorability ratings, Perry with 36% and Scott with 35%, but the gap widens significantly for unfavorable ratings and if they have an opinion on the candidate.

32% view the Republican incumbent unfavorably, while Scott has 17% viewing him that way. The most significant gap is how the candidates are known to those polled. 31% said they didn’t know enough about Perry for form an opinion which is considerably less than the Democratic candidate’s 48%.

Half of those who responded identified as Republicans, while 35% said they were Democrats and 14% were Independents.

Despite the GOP registration advantage, Republicans only held a slight lead of 47-46 over the Democratic candidates for the 2018 generic ballot.

The Scott campaign saw the results as a positive for their bid.

“We are in a horse race; this is a dead heat,” said Campaign Manager Jason O’Malley. “As the poll shows, eight out of ten people are excited to vote in November and you can feel they are ready to vote for change – George Scott.”

The full memo can be found here.

This article has been updated with comment from the Scott campaign. 

3 Responses

  1. The mood in here rural Cumberland County is surprisingly encouraging. Lots of yard signs. Not the ones jammed in some Right-of-Way somewhere. The ones carefully placed and mowed around on private property. As a native, I’ve not often seen this for a Dem. He’s much more of a bold progressive than I thought he would be in the General. I don’t have much more to donate to candidates right now, but I’ll try to scrape up a little.

  2. Perry has demonstrated he’s no man of principle, and was just as happy as every other “fiscal conservative” to vote for wildly irresponsible tax cuts for the ultra-rich and spending increases, racking up the national credit card despite running on tearjerker stories about the national debt crushing our grandchildren. Voting to cut funding for our veterans was particularly appalling since he loves to play the veteran card himself. He is a Trumper through and through. It’s just disgraceful.

Comments are closed.

  • Reader Poll: Have You Requested a Mail-In Ballot?

    • Yes. I enjoy mail-in voting. (50%)
    • No. I am going to the poll. (50%)

    Total Voters: 121

    Loading ... Loading ...
Continue to Browser


To install tap and choose
Add to Home Screen