Close this search box.

Gov. Wolf Creates Redistricting Commission, GOP Leadership Says It Ignores Large Parts of PA

The redistricting debate once again takes center stage in Pennsylvania politics.

Last Thursday, Gov. Tom Wolf signed an executive order to create the Pennsylvania Redistricting Reform Commission,

The 15 member commission, which will be chaired by David Thornburgh, president and CEO of the Philadelphia good government group Committee of Seventy and son of former Gov. Dick Thornburgh, will include 11 appointed members from Wolf and 4 more will be selected by the General Assembly, one from each chamber’s respective Democratic and Republican caucus, according to the PLS Reporter.

Below are the 11 appointed by Wolf.

  • Lee Ann Banaszak, Penn State University
  • Dr. Damary Bonilla-Rodriguez, Governor’s Advisory Commission on Latino Affairs
  • Susan Carty, President, League of Women Voters of Pennsylvania
  • Kathy Dahlkemper, Erie County Executive
  • Charlie Dent, Former Congressman
  • Amanda Holt, Lehigh County Commissioner
  • Rev. Robert Johnson, Tindley Temple United Methodist Church
  • Sharmain Matlock-Turner, President, Urban Affairs Coalition
  • Wes Pegden, Carnegie Mellon University
  • David Thornburgh, President and CEO, Committee of Seventy
  • Secretary of the Commonwealth or designee

“This commission will bring together diverse experts and citizens to explore ways that Pennsylvania could use policies, technology and data to curb gerrymandering and ensure fair maps,” Wolf said in a statement. “There has been significant bipartisan support for bringing more fairness to this process. The goal of this commission is to hear from experts and citizens about what can be done to make this process more fair.”

Pennsylvania’s Congressional map was redrawn earlier this year after the state Supreme Court deemed the previous one unconstitutional and drawn in the Republicans favor. The state will redraw the congressional and state legislative district boundaries after the 2020 census.

Republican leadership in Harrisburg believes the new commission largely ignores rural areas in the state and gives Commission members a “responsibility that he does not have the authority to give.”

“With no input from the General Assembly, the Governor issued an Executive Order where he turned his back on both the state and federal constitutions and embarked on another go-it-alone strategy,” said Senate President Pro Tempore Joe Scarnati, House Speaker Mike Turzai, Senate Majority Leader Jake Corman and House Majority Leader-elect Brian Cutler in a joint statement. “The Governor has created a Commission that ignores large swaths of the Commonwealth, specifically rural communities, and charged Commission members with a responsibility that he does not have the authority to give.”

“We will not be props in his theater that is an attempt to be a make-shift alternative to the federal and state constitutions and will have no practical effect,” the GOP leaders continued. “The fact remains that under the constitutions the responsibility for redistricting falls to the General Assembly.”

The PLSReporter reports that the new commission will not have the authority to draw new legislative lines, but “if an amendment was passed during the 2019-20 session, then immediately taken up and pushed through early in the 2021-22 session, a new redistricting process could be presented to voters during the 2021 primary and used to draw new maps.”

The committee plans to travel the state and hold public meetings before sharing the report with the public.

9 Responses

  1. Well said, Dilbert. Let’s try and keep our comments as well-informed as possible to lift our discourse.

  2. Notably absent is Carol Kuniholm (chair and co-founder of Fair Districts PA).

    Was she asked?

    The commission should come up with a NON-PARTISAN set of rules for computers to draw the maps using the census data and municipal/precinct boundaries. In this day and age, there is ZERO reason for human beings to haggle over boundary lines and play partisan games.

    Currently D’s and R’s use gerrymandering software designed to maximize partisan advantage. Just run those same f*cking programs with the goal of minimizing any partisan advantage (like leaving out registration and turnout data from the input). Duh!

  3. So all of is that live in rural areas who didn’t want him voted back in anyways will STILL have NO SAY in anything in OUR STATE!

  4. A redistricting commissioner who has one republican member, a Republican that works for MSNBC. As always, Governor Wolf shows a level of partisan hackiness that only he can. Thank god for him the FakeNews Media will make him look like a statesman. If it wasn’t for them the people would see who he really is.

    1. First, Congressman Dent is with CNN, second, Amanda Holt is a very conservative, Republican County Commissioner who’s worked extensively on this issue.

      The commission will not have the authority to draw new lines, only an amendment in the next two sessions can do that.

      Maybe you should take your feigned outrage to the comment section of Fox News.

  5. So the Republican legislature that drew the unconstitutional maps is complaining with stupid reasons.

  • Does the NYC Verdict Make You More or Less Likely to Vote For Trump in 2024?

    • Less Likely (36%)
    • More Likely (34%)
    • Makes No Difference (30%)

    Total Voters: 112

    Loading ... Loading ...
Continue to Browser


To install tap and choose
Add to Home Screen