Close this search box.

It’s Time We Heard From Fetterman’s Doctors About Condition

What do we really know about the health prognosis of John Fetterman?

The 52-year-old lieutenant governor is resting at his home in Braddock after suffering a stroke on May 13. He spent nine days in a hospital in Lancaster, including Election Night.

In a statement released by his campaign on May 17, Fetterman said he underwent a “standard procedure to implant a pacemaker with a defibrillator.” The procedure was done to “address the underlying cause of his stroke, atrial fibrillation (A-fib), by regulating his heart rate and rhythm.”

During atrial fibrillation, according to the Mayo Clinic website, “the heart’s upper chambers (the atria) beat chaotically and irregularly — out of sync with the lower chambers (the ventricles) of the heart. For many people, A-fib may have no symptoms. However, A-fib may cause a fast, pounding heartbeat (palpitations), shortness of breath or weakness.”

“I am feeling great, but per my doctor’s orders, and Gisele’s orders, I am going to continue to rest and recover,” Fetterman said in a statement to the press on Sunday. “Later this week I will have a follow-up visit with my doctors at Penn Medicine Lancaster General Hospital.”

As the Pennsylvania Senate contest is among the most important in the country in determining the balance of power in the chamber, Fetterman’s condition has national implications. No less important: It also has a statewide impact, as he is the current lieutenant governor of the state. 

And yet it took his campaign over 48 hours to inform the Commonwealth and the public about his health scare. And we have yet to hear from a cardiologist directly about Fetterman’s condition. His wife, Giselle, and his Senate campaign have released statements about his health. But no one with a medical degree or license to practice.

That’s not right.

Fetterman is an elected official in the Commonwealth. For over 48 hours, we did not know where he was or his physical condition, beyond hearing from a campaign spokesman that he was sick and unable to make a Millersville University appearance.

Yes, John Fetterman is a candidate. And campaigns share information out of a firehose when they want to … and an eye-dropper when they don’t.

When was Governor Tom Wolf made aware of the situation? How about Senate President Pro Tempore Jake Corman – third in line to the governor’s chair and the official who temporarily took over Fetterman’s responsibilities as lieutenant governor when he underwent the procedure to implant a pacemaker?

Why was it the Fetterman campaign, and not the lieutenant governor’s office or a physician, that finally told the Commonwealth what happened? And why did it take until 3:34 p.m. on May 15 to issue a press release with the details?

“As the lieutenant governor undergoes a standard procedure, there is a process in place to ensure that our government remains fully operational,” said Wolf last Tuesday. “This is a short-term transfer of power, and we hope and expect the lieutenant governor to resume his duties very soon.”

A press release from the Governor’s office explained: “Per Pennsylvania law, a declaration was sent from a majority of ​designated cabinet secretaries and the President Pro Tempore to the General Assembly stating that the lieutenant governor is unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office. The declaration was sent on May 17 after the governor was informed that the lieutenant governor was going to undergo a standard procedure.” 

The next day, Fetterman sent a written declaration to the General Assembly that he is again able to discharge the powers and duties of his office. That would enable him to resume his duties at the expiration of four days — on May 23.

Fetterman’s primary duty now is rest and recovery at home. Another trip to Lancaster is scheduled for Friday to visit with his doctors. Will we hear more from them at this point? 

Until then, we are left with speculation from others on the true meaning of his procedure and the prognosis for the 52-year-old going forward.

The New York Times reports that some medical specialists are troubled by the details that they have heard given their knowledge of treatment of a stroke.

“Medical specialists asked questions about Mr. Fetterman’s treatment with a defibrillator,” the Times said. “They say it would make sense only if he has a different condition that puts him at risk of sudden death, like cardiomyopathy — a weakened heart muscle. Such a heart condition may have caused the blood clot. Or, the doctors say the campaign could be correct about afib causing the clot.”

An implantable cardioverter-defibrillator (ICD), a small battery-powered device placed in the chest to detect and stop irregular heartbeats, is the main treatment for anyone who has survived cardiac arrest. ICDs are increasingly used in people at high risk of sudden cardiac arrest. An ICD lowers the risk of sudden death from cardiac arrest more than medication alone.

Other reasons provided for why a patient would benefit from an ICD include:

  • A history of coronary artery disease and heart attack that has weakened the heart
  • An enlarged heart muscle
  • A genetic heart condition that increases the risk of dangerously fast heart rhythms, such as some types of long QT syndrome


Back in January, Sen. Ben Ray Lujan (D-N.M.) suffered a stroke and did not get to a hospital in time, requiring surgery to remove a portion of his skull. He missed five weeks of work and was able to return to the Senate. But he didn’t have to concern himself with running a full-scale campaign for the office.

While we appreciate the privacy that is held by family in medical emergencies, Fetterman first needs to remember that he is a public servant with official responsibilities beyond running for the U.S. Senate. 

The people of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania deserve to know the physical health of their statewide elected officials. And we do not know the condition of John Fetterman as of today.


13 Responses

  1. Speaking of the LG race, what is wrong with former loser Republican LG candidate Teddy Daniels? Says he’ll be more dangerous than ever. posted that you’re entitled to nothing, funny coming from a guy who takes disability checks while holding jobs and a guy who accepted a house from a veteran charity then sold it for profit. Daniels seems to think he’s gonna be the next Rush Limbaugh or at least a blend of Nugent and Tucker. Hello ego! Please tell us one more time about your short time in combat. We haven’t heard about it in the last ten seconds!

  2. He had a defibrillator implanted and he’s resting, per his doctors’ orders. He’s posted on Twitter and he looks good.

    What more do you want to know? If he gave us a detailed medical report you’d be picking that apart and probably misinterpreting it.

    Find something important to do, like questioning why the Republican Party had three carpetbaggers in the primary and the Democrats had none. That seat was for sale, and the Democrats weren’t buying.

  3. Paltry, partisan polemics, Mr. Ulrich. I recognize your employers are right-wingers but that does not excuse or even explain this shabby work.

    Carry on, clingers.

  4. It’s a shame that Steve isn’t more concerned about how the two leading GOP candidates are both carpet-bagging frauds who don’t live in Pennsylvania to begin with.

    And the Steve was really concerned about doctors and medical integrity will be asking a lot more questions about Dr Oz and what a complete and total charlatan he is. Dr Oz sells fake medical supplements to desperate people who can’t afford real medicine. The Dems want to reduce prescription drug prices. Clearly this goes against Dr Oz’s financial interests.

  5. I agree that Fetterman should be more forthcoming about his state of health, particularly if would prevent him from effectively campaigning for the Senate seat. And, I was put off by the 48-hour delayed initial announcement (which seemed more like an attempt to get ahead of the Times story).

    I’m not worried about John fulfilling his duties as lieutenant governor, which in Pennsylvania, is practically a no-show job to begin with.

    Fetterment had a serious medical condition and he got it resolved with real doctors and real medicine. His likely opponent, Dr Oz, would have pushed him on some herbal supplement or other nonsense.

  6. So you want Fetterman’s Doctors to violate HIPAA laws regarding doctor/patient confidentiality?

    1. No.. it’s common for political candidates and elected officials to authorize their doctors to speak on their medical condition.

      Steve is clearly asking for the Fetterman campaign to grant this authorization to his doctor

  7. What’s the GOP conspiracy theory that you want to spin here, Politics PA? Hit job opinion piece. I feel we have been told plenty about his condition. Opinions are like assholes; we all have one.

  8. This is a total BS, partisan post. Comparing an a-fib blood bollus to a brain bleed? Come on. And have YOU ever checked in to a hospital on a Friday night? You would be lucky to see an actual doctor by Sunday morning – as you well know. And the Times’ hit piece was issued when they were still trying to pump up their corporate boy Conor. You really showed your true Club For Growth colors here.

    1. The Republicans made a much bigger mistake nominating Ding Dong Doug the Insurrectionist for Governor, but hey…. Here we are.

  9. We know John isn’t truthful, just like when he says he didn’t point the gun at the black kid

  10. For a healthy looking 52 year old man to have a stroke that laid him up for 9 days in the hospital is significant. Open heart surgery you are in and out of the hospital in 3 days. So, obviously to be in the hospital for 9 days is on it’s own serious.

  • Reader Poll: Should President Joe Biden Step Aside?

    • Yes. He should step aside because of his age, declining ability to do the job. (45%)
    • No. He should not step aside. (39%)
    • Yes. He should step aside because he can't beat Donald Trump. (15%)

    Total Voters: 231

    Loading ... Loading ...
Continue to Browser


To install tap and choose
Add to Home Screen