Close this search box.

National Journal: Perry Stays on Top 20 Most Vulnerable House List

One Pennsylvania congressional race remains in National Journal’s 20 most vulnerable House seats in the county. 

NJ Hotline’s Kirk A. Bado, Leah Askarinam and Josh Kraushaar placed Pennsylvania’s 10th Congressional District held by Rep. Scott Perry (R-York) as the 17th most likely House seat to flip in 2020. 

There are eight GOP held seats that rank higher on the list as more vulnerable than Perry’s seat, although the York County Republican is the third highest rated incumbent Republican seeking reelection in danger of losing his seat. 

Perry’s race did move down the list two spots in comparison to the previous ranking that had him as the 15th most vulnerable House incumbent and the highest rated incumbent Republican seeking reelection in a vulnerable district. 

NJ Hotline’s most recent ratings released on July 22 cited Democrats being “thrilled” about challenger Euguene DePasquale being their candidate, although there should “probably be” more excitement behind former Vice President Joe Biden’s candidacy in the state.

“Democrats are thrilled about their candidate, Eugene DePasquale,” noted in the ranking. “But they should probably be more thrilled about Biden’s candidacy in Pennsylvania. According to DePasquale’s internal polling from late May, Perry led 50-47 percent. But the national environment has improved for Democrats since then, and DePasquale also enjoyed an edge in Q2 fundraising.”

“In the end, Perry’s fate, like so much of the rest of the country’s, may come down to Pennsylvania suburbs,” the rating concludes with. 

Previous rankings have cited DePasquale, the state’s Democratic Auditor General, success in the district by carrying nearly 51% of the vote during his successful 2016 bid for Auditor General, while Trump was also on the ballot. 

The race in the 10th Congressional District appears to be the closest House race to watch in Pennsylvania this fall, according to several national ratings outlets. 

The Cook Political Report moved Perry’s race in early August from Leans Republican to Toss Up, which it still remains today. In late November, Politico introduced their first House ratings and placed Perry’s race as a Toss Up, which it still remains today. Roll Call currently has Perry’s race as Tilt Republican

Although Perry is the lone Pennsylvania incumbent on the top 20 list, Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick (R-Bucks) was on NJ Hotline’s “First Four Out” of races that didn’t quite qualify for the top 20, but still warranted recognition. 

Bado wrote for NJ Hotline that Biden’s coattails in the Bucks County suburban district “should lift any generic Democrat over a generic Republican in a district Hillary Clinton carried in 2016,” although Fitzpatrick’s family history in the district coupled with his “reputation for bipartisanship” makes it a tougher flip for Democrats. He also cited internal polls on both sides; GOP polls showing Fitzpatrick leading Democratic challenger Christina Finello by double digits and Democratic backed polls showing a neck and neck race in PA1. One common denominator of all polling shows Biden leading Trump in the district, although Bado writes “the question for now is how far ahead of the president Fitzpatrick has to run to defend his seat.”

The Top 20 National Journal rankings can be found here

The First Four Out National Journal rankings can be found here.

10 Responses

  1. I think Perry is definitely in trouble, but I believe Fitzpatrick will win Bucks County. His brother was well-respected by voters on both sides of the aisle and voters connect the two.

  2. PoliticsPA should be ashamed of themselves for letting a liar stealer coward fraud use my real fake name and post like this guy. Must be run by liberal gutless rubber chickens

    1. Scott Perry and Fitzpatrick are in political trouble with the Biden wave. Sometimes when government fails to deliver the voters want to be heard. All of us posting here will spend hours debating obtuse points in politics but the average voter is more direct. They see covid19 as a failure in the way the federal government handled it and Trump does little to redeem himself with the voters. The election is over. It will be a Biden wave and Ftizpatrick will be swept out of office. Perry may lose only because it is a Biden wave.

  3. Could there be anymore of a fake news source than Cook Political Report and NJ Hotline. Flaming liberal lame stream rags. We need legitimate news sources like NRA TV and OAN Network

  4. Perry is terrible, he cares more about pleasing his child abuse covering-up buddy Jim Jordan than he does helping his district. One of the benefits of a blue wave this year would be Trump dragging down Perry.

  • Reader Poll: Should President Joe Biden Step Aside?

    • Yes. He should step aside because of his age, declining ability to do the job. (45%)
    • No. He should not step aside. (39%)
    • Yes. He should step aside because he can't beat Donald Trump. (15%)

    Total Voters: 231

    Loading ... Loading ...
Continue to Browser


To install tap and choose
Add to Home Screen