Close this search box.

PA GOP Delegation Splits on AHCA

Source: CNN
Source: CNN

While the American Health Care Act (AHCA) passed the House, the PA GOP delegation split their votes on the bill.  No state had more Republicans vote no on the bill than Pennsylvania.  

Congressmen Ryan Costello (R-Chester), Charlie Dent (R-Lehigh), Brian Fitzpatrick (R-Bucks), and Pat Meehan (R-Delaware) voted against the AHCA.  Congressmen Lou Barletta (R-Luzerne), Mike Kelly (R-Butler), Tom Marino (R-Lycoming), Tim Murphy (R-Allegheny), Scott Perry (R-York), Keith Rothfus (R-Allegheny), Bill Shuster (R-Bedford), Lloyd Smucker (R-Lancaster), and Glenn Thompson (R-Centre) all voted for the bill.  

Fitzpatrick voiced concerns over the opioid epidemic and other concerns with the legislation.  

“Throughout this debate, I’ve made clear my concerns about the proposed legislation – including its impact on our response to the opioid epidemic crushing our community, something I’ve made a primary focus in Congress. Despite some positive portions, I could not support this bill with these issues unresolved,” Fitzpatrick said in a statement.

Kelly stuck to the Republican message about the bill after the vote.  

“The American Health Care Act represents the beginning of a better health care system that is patient-centered, choice-filled, and cost-lowering. With this bill, and future action taken by Congress and the Trump administration, American families and workers will be guaranteed access to affordable, high-quality health insurance in a competitive market based on freedom and flexibility,” Kelly said in a statement.  

All Congressional Democrats, including the five from Pennsylvania, voted no on the AHCA.  

Ahead of the vote, Governor Tom Wolf, who pushed for Congress to vote against the bill, sent out a tweet thanking the Pennsylvania Democrats who would vote against the bill, and the Republicans who had publicly said they would vote against the bill.

After the vote, Wolf reiterated his stance against the bill.

“I thank the Republicans and Democrats who voted ‘no’ today. We can only hope that the United States Senate cares more about the people they were elected to serve,” Wolf said.

Democratic Senator Bob Casey immediately condemned the bill’s passage, and vowed to fight against it in the Senate.  

“Republicans in the House of Representatives just delivered an economic punch to the gut of middle class families in Pennsylvania. What passed today isn’t a health care bill, but a scheme to cut taxes for millionaires and big corporations, a giveaway for special interests, and forces middle class families in Pennsylvania to pay more for their health care,” Casey said in a statement.  

“Now that this legislation is coming to the Senate, I am redoubling my effort to fight like hell on behalf of families, seniors and individuals with disabilities who will be immeasurably harmed by it,” Casey continued.  

The Pennsylvania Democratic Party went on the offensive against the bill ahead of the vote.  

“Pennsylvanians simply cannot afford to continue down the road of repealing the ACA, and any congressperson who votes for this disastrous piece of legislation should be ashamed,” Pa. Dems Chairman Marcel L. Groen said in a statement.

9 Responses

  1. Maybe the democrats will now vote for Brian Fitzpatrick. You can’t make this stuff up. Fitzpatrick probably believes this is the case. We really miss Brian out here in California. Maybe he can move back here and run for Congress. He now has the carpetbagging experience.

  2. SENECA: “At lease” (sic)? some people can write proper English. Or is that the native American spelling? Like it is Obama flying to FL for weekend golf, when he’s not at another of his golf properties “working”.

  3. Bill Shuster voted for the bill? Why? Did it give goodies to the airlines?

  4. So Lloyd Smucker voted for the bill. I lived in the 6th CD my whole life until gerrymandering created a Danzig corridor to connect Reading with Lancaster County. I would be very happy to explain to him exactly what a pre-existing condition really means for some Americans.

  5. @David Diano. In which case Wolf’s tweet remains an Obama-style mini-lesson in hypocrisy. At lease Wolf doesn’t seem to have been playing golf when he sent it.

  6. vile subhumans, all of them. voting them out isn’t good enough–they need to be taken out

  7. PA needs to institute single payer or something like ACA to protect Pennsylvanians from GOP congress and Trump taking away their health care.


    “three of the four Congressmen targeted by the DCCC for the 2018 elections”

    Hmmm, maybe the targeting helped sway their votes.

  8. Governor Wolf’s tweet is pure birdcrap. No matter how sweet his tweet may be for for FItzpatrick, Costello, and Meehan, these are three of the four Congressmen targeted by the DCCC for the 2018 elections.

    I doubt that the governor has any plans to intercede with the DNC or the DCCC on their behalf. He is just going through the motions to be nice to useful idiots.

  9. Two questions…how the hell are Mike Kelley and Keith Rothfus still in Congress? Morons in stereo.

  • Reader Poll: Should President Joe Biden Step Aside?

    • Yes. He should step aside because of his age, declining ability to do the job. (45%)
    • No. He should not step aside. (39%)
    • Yes. He should step aside because he can't beat Donald Trump. (15%)

    Total Voters: 231

    Loading ... Loading ...
Continue to Browser


To install tap and choose
Add to Home Screen