Close this search box.

Restrepo Confirmation Process Underway

Felipe-RestrepoAlmost 7 months to the day after Judge Luis Felipe Restrepo was nominated to serve on the Third Circuit of the U.S. Appeals Court by Pres. Obama, the Senate Judiciary Committee finally began his confirmation process.

Restrepo answered several questions from the three senators in attendance, about his previous experience and the two cases in which the Third Circuit Court overturned his decisions.

Upon introducing Restrepo, PA Sens. Pat Toomey and Bob Casey offered their support to the current District Court Judge for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. Restrepo was unanimously confirmed to that position by the Senate in 2013.

During the short hearing, Restrepo told the senators how he has dealt with conflicts of interest, and said he believed drug sentencing guidelines are “draconian.”

Many on the outside – and even a few on the inside – have called out Republican leadership in the Senate over a lack of judicial confirmations this year, including former Senate majority leader Harry Reid (D-NV).

“This is a blatant rejection of the Senate’s constitutional duties,” Reid said from the Senate floor on Monday.

There is something of a small crisis in the country’s judicial system with 58 judicial vacancies and only 13 nominees pending. 26 of those seats have been deemed judicial emergencies by the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts.

Yesterday, Sen. Toomey tweeted his support for Restrepo, but still faces criticism for his handling of the confirmation process.

At the beginning of the hearing, Toomey said he hopes Restrepo will be unanimously confirmed again “this year,” sparking concerns over how much longer the process will take.

Other Senators have pushed for prompt confirmations for judges from their states, but it remains to be seen whether Toomey will do the same.

On May 12th, the City Council of Pittsburgh adopted a resolution urging the Senate to confirm Restrepo before another judicial vacancy opens on July 1st.

Before taking his seat on the Third Circuit bench, Restrepo must clear the Senate Judiciary Committee and be confirmed by a full vote in the Senate.

3 Responses

  1. @SAL, Senatorial courtesy doesn’t apply to Court of Appeals nominations and many of the District Court vacancies are in states represented by 2 Democratic Senators.

    25 of those nominations could be made without Republican input (using the list at the link above):
    – (4) Court of International Trade
    – (1) 3rd Circuit
    – (2) 5th Circuit
    – (1) 6th Circuit
    – (2) 7th Circuit
    – (1) 8th Circuit
    – (1) 11th Circuit
    – (1) Federal Circuit
    – (1) Massachusetts District Court
    – (5) New York District Courts
    – (3) New Jersey District Courts
    – (1) Maryland District Court
    – (2) California District Courts

    But don’t let facts get in the way of reality.

    After the lame duck court packing of late 2014, Obama really shouldn’t get anyone else since Reid went nuclear and broke with Senate tradition. Many of those vacancies were the very ones that Democrats wouldn’t let Bush fill during his term.

  2. @KSDF– Judicial nomination procedure is to allow Senators to recommend judicial candidates from their home states to the President to then choose from and nominate to the Senate. A troubling number of Republican Senators have failed to do so, or have placed senatorial holds on their own recommendations for inexplicable reasons (Pat Toomey is one, which is why this process is taking so long here). This actually isn’t the President’s fault at all. The blame lies entirely at the feet of Senate Republicans and Majority Leader Mitch McConnell.

  3. “There is something of a small crisis in the country’s judicial system with 58 judicial vacancies and only 13 nominees pending”

    Wouldn’t that mean that the crisis is the President’s own doing? How is President Obama’s inability to select more than 25% of the nominees needed to fill the bench the Republicans fault?

  • Reader Poll: Should President Joe Biden Step Aside?

    • Yes. He should step aside because of his age, declining ability to do the job. (45%)
    • No. He should not step aside. (39%)
    • Yes. He should step aside because he can't beat Donald Trump. (15%)

    Total Voters: 231

    Loading ... Loading ...
Continue to Browser


To install tap and choose
Add to Home Screen