The Politics of Energy Independence

As Russia’s invasion of Ukraine intensifies and the threat of an expanding conflict in the region looms, questions are being raised in Pennsylvania about energy independence and the role of the Keystone State.

In many respects, history is repeating itself as America and its allies find themselves drawn into a conflict that has links to fossil fuels – its production and its consumption.

The European Union is the largest importer of natural gas in the world with the biggest share coming from Russia (41 percent). In comparison, the U.S. imports about 11 percent of crude oil from Russia.

Now, the Biden Administration must decide a path to follow – impose sanctions on Russia’s gas exports and possibly see American energy costs rise, or find another option.

Pennsylvania politicians have staked their positions on the subject, mostly with the caveat that many of the problems in the crisis were caused by the Biden Administration.

“We have to consider additional sanctions” on Russia’s oil and gas industry, said Democratic Sen. Bob Casey, adding that a proposed Joe Manchin-Lisa Murkowski bill that would block the U.S. government and U.S. companies from importing any Russian crude oil or petroleum is something he is taking under consideration.

Gov. Tom Wolf went after House Environmental Resources & Energy Committee Chair Daryl Metcalfe (R-Butler) for his criticism of his administration’s response to the crisis. He accused Metcalfe of “seizing” on the war in Ukraine to “increase the profits of the natural gas industry.”

Metcalfe penned a letter from his committee to Wolf, stating “Pennsylvania has never been in a better position to power the world. The commonwealth has a natural bounty of oil, gas, and coal that can heat homes, generate manufacturing feedstock, and fuel democracies far and wide. You know of our immense potential, yet the State has been hamstrung by regulation, bans, time-intensive permitting, RGGI, and further taxation while you support energy means that cannot possibly power the needs of the 21st century.”

Mr. Biden owns this energy crisis, which is the direct result of his administration crippling domestic production, making us more vulnerable to global market fluctuations such as those caused by Russian aggressions in Ukraine,” said Rep. Glenn Thompson (R-Centre) in a statement.

“The regulatory blanket and the uncertainty has stopped capital investment,” GOP senate candidate Dave McCormick told FOX Business’ Maria Bartiromo. “We need to streamline the pipeline permitting process, which is one of the big constraints in Pennsylvania. We need to pull back on the regulatory blanket.”

“We as a nation say ‘from now on when we say we need energy, we make energy,’” said Republican opponent Mehmet Oz told abc27’s Dennis Owens. “We don’t let pipelines get stopped halfway down the construction pipeline because a bunch of activists get upset about the possibility they might have an ecological impact.”

According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, Pennsylvania’s marketed natural gas production, primarily from the Marcellus Shale, reached a record 7.1 trillion cubic feet in 2020, and the state is the nation’s second-largest natural gas producer after Texas.

GOP gubernatorial candidate Lou Barletta told City and State that “I will work to finish the Mariner pipeline to ship clean and safe Pennsylvania natural gas out of the Port of Philadelphia to places like Europe, so we can undermine Russia’s strength and ability to leverage their energy dominance.”

State House Majority Leader Kerry Benninghoff penned an op-ed where he said, “We need to make sure we are doing all we can to increase production and use our own domestic fuel sources, including Pennsylvania natural gas. On any given day, Pennsylvania produces nearly 20 percent of the entire nation’s natural gas supply.”

“The United States can change course,” said state senator Gene Yaw (R-Lycoming) in a press release. “We can ramp up energy production with the same urgency we experienced when manufacturers pivoted to make masks and ventilators at the onset of the pandemic. We can ease Biden-era policies meant to restrict oil and gas production and exports. We can greenlight Keystone and other pipelines. And we can unleash our plentiful gas supply right here in Pennsylvania to help with that mammoth effort.”

Rep. Seth Grove (R-York), the chairman of the House State Government Committee, said he would soon be introducing a bill to increase natural gas drilling and distribution in Pennsylvania in light of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.  

Grove said that his End Russian Aggression Act would increase drilling in the state, fund pipelines to get gas to markets, reform the drilling permit process and keep Pennsylvania from entering the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, currently a project among 11 states to reduce carbon dioxide emissions in power generation. 

GOP Senate candidate George Bochetto said, “I will advocate for energy independence and for energy jobs here in Pennsylvania. Our nation must be energy independent. We must go back to exporting oil and natural gas to Europe, and cutting off the lifeblood of Putin’s military.”

5 Responses

  1. For those ramping up the bullshit, here’s a few facts to get in your way….

    For those saying “Open Keystone Pipeline” here are a few things you need to know…
    1. It is open. It currently transports 540,000 barrels of oil per day.
    2. Keystone Pipeline carries “tar sands oil” which is not used to make gasoline
    3. The oil it carries comes from Canada, not the United States. It is still imported.
    4. Keystone Pipeline is privately owned by a foreign company by the name of TransCanada.
    5. What you are referring to is Keystone Pipeline XL. The XL portion is an extension to the existing Keystone Pipeline.
    6. Keystone Pipeline XL was 8% constructed. It is still years away from 100% completion.
    7. TransCanada has canceled the project completely. That means the OWNER is no longer building or looking to finish the project.
    8. TransCanada obtained the land to build the extension on through eminent domain lawsuits. A private, foreign company, stealing land from American citizens who did not want it on their property.
    9. TransCanada, the owner of both Keystone Pipeline and Keystone Pipeline XL admitted that the XL portion would INCREASE fuel prices in the Midwest.

  2. Republicans will use any crisis to ramp up their lies and bullshit. FACT – there is no reason to ramp up gas drilling because there are many of the wells drilled during the Marcellus drilling boom a decade ago that sit capped today. Why, because the gas industry doesn’t need the gas from those wells to meet current demand. Sure they will gladly drill more wells and cap them because it will give them more potential inventory to bring to the market in 10 or 20 years. BUT, vicious circle here… You realize the more inventory they have in reserve, the harder they will fight to block alternative energies that will lessen the value of their inventory reserves. Think of it this way from 100 years ago. The fat cat businessman that had 10,000 horses to sell to the public was out there lobbying and fighting against the iron horse / automobile industry. WHY? Because the minute the consumers realized they wanted an automobile instead of horses pulling a buggy, his inventory of horses probably lost 90% of their value.

    So YES, let’s stop buying oil from Russia, but there is still plenty of domestic and foreign oil to meet the demand. And maybe it is smarter to continue to aggressively develop to alternatives that will be domestically produced and begin to phase out the use of massive quantities of oil. But let’s stop allowing the lobby for the oil companies to totally manipulate our political decision making. Sadly, while both parties are guilty of this, the GOP officials are truly the whores for the energy sector.

    1. If we can get it ourselves we can make our own price! Not hard to figure out there liberal.

  3. Sanction Russian Gas and inflation kicks in. So, USA doesn’t buy from Russia then China will. At best Russian gas sanction is symbolic.

  • Who are you voting for in the PA Supreme Court race?

    • Dan McCaffery (61%)
    • Carolyn Carluccio (37%)
    • Still undecided (2%)

    Total Voters: 344

    Loading ... Loading ...
Continue to Browser


To install tap and choose
Add to Home Screen