Wanted: Primary Challenger to Tim Murphy

By Keegan Gibson, Managing Editor

Several conservative activists are sowing the seeds of a Tea Party challenge to Rep. Tim Murphy, PoliticsPA has learned.

People affiliated with the PA Coalition for Responsible Government, among other Allegheny County conservative groups, are working behind the scenes to highlight Murphy’s moderate record on labor issues, and to recruit a candidate willing to challenge the five-term Congressman.

“We’re testing the waters to determine if there is interest in someone challenging,” said Bob Howard, the Republican candidate for Allegheny County Controller. “It really involves Representative Murphy’s position as it relates to labor.”

Several conservatives pointed to a vote last week as their most potent criticism of Murphy. The Congressman joined 27 Republicans who crossed party lines to block an effort to de-fund President Obama’s Executive Order 13502, which encourages the use of union labor by government contractors for military and Veterans Affairs construction projects. It ended up passing by one vote, 204 to 203.

“His vote was the deciding vote that kept in place an executive order requiring union workers on government projects,” said Howard.

“We’ve talked with several people in the area who have been involved with running previously. At this point, they don’t want to be mentioned as possible primary challengers to the Congressman,” Howard added.

“I know many people in his district and many grassroots leaders who are very upset,” said Pittsburgh Tea Party organizer Jeff Steigerwalt. “I think somebody is going to come forward and say, ‘All right, I’ll challenge him.’”

Steigerwalt managed Melissa Haluszczak’s campaign against Rep. Mike Doyle last year.

“I have talked to people who are very interested in challenging him,” regardless of redistricting, said Steigerwalt. “The people I talked to were pretty much sure that they would be in his area – Mount Lebanon, Upper St. Clair.”

“They’re working to recruit a challenger to Murphy now,” said an Allegheny County Republican insider. The source characterized the people pushing the effort as “Tea Party people,” who are “active in conservative groups, but none of them are on Republican committee.”

The source said conservative leaders have already spoken to several prospective candidates, including a lobbyist for one of the universities in Pittsburgh.

And when Keith Rothfus announced his intention to launch another bid for Congress in 2012, it was initially reported that he would proceed with a campaign even if he were redistricted into the 18th. His campaign manager later ruled out a primary challenge to Murphy.

PoliticsPA is seeking comment from Coalition leader Greg Wrightstone.

Murphy’s office declined to elaborate on 2012 campaign, citing the uncertainty of redistricting.

“It’s too early to speculate about a campaign race in a district that isn’t even drawn yet. With the state legislative reapportionment process still underway, the exact configuration of PA congressional districts remains to be seen,” said Murphy Chief of Staff Susan Mosychuk.

“At this point, Congressman Murphy’s focus is on working for his constituents who overwhelmingly re-elected him with 67.3 % of the vote. He secured a decisive victory in the 18th congressional district — where only 37% are registered Republican voters — because of his independent voting record on supporting lower taxes, ending government bailouts and “stimulus” spending, and overturning the federal takeover of the healthcare system.”

Part of Murphy’s record is a history of cooperation with labor unions.

As of their 2010 scorecard, the most recent available, the AFL-CIO gave Murphy a lifetime voting score of 48 percent. It was the highest score of any Pennsylvania Republican and fifth highest among GOPers nationally.

According to OpenSecrets.org, labor has been a friend to Murphy as well. Since his election in 2002, the Congressman has received $477,700 from various labor union PACs. Though, in 2010, the AFL-CIO gave its endorsement to Murphy opponent Dan Connolly.

That said, southwestern PA is well known for its strong history of labor unions, and it is not uncommon even for Republicans in the area to be union friendly.

For the most part, Murphy’s record is that of a mainstream Republican. He has a party loyalty vote percentage of 89 percent so far this session, higher than Reps. Mike Fitzpatrick, Jim Gerlach, Charlie Dent, Pat Meehan and Todd Platts according to the Washington Post’s U.S. Congress Votes Database. His record in previous sessions is similar (87 percent in the 111th, 85 percent in the 110th, 94 percent in the 109th and 97 percent in the 108th).

And any Republican challenger would face a steep climb against Murphy. He has over $635,000 cash on hand, according to his latest filing with the FEC. He won by a 2-1 margin last year, and some insiders predict that he will have over a million on hand by January 2012.

He was liked well enough by Republicans that his name has been floated as a possible challenger to Senator Bob Casey. He has reportedly deferred on that race, and some GOP insiders that PoliticsPA interviewed for this story believe Murphy intends to step down after two to three more terms in the House – leaving ambitious elected officials little cause to oppose him outwardly.

Those seeking to organize a challenger for Murphy understand the tough task ahead.

“Our agenda is not just to have a primary challenger,” said Howard, when asked about the political challenge of defeating Murphy. “Our agenda would also be to move the Congressman to an agenda that is more in line with limited government and freedom. That would be a great outcome.”

8 Responses

  1. Most independent film buffs will fondly remember the character study drama “Shame” from 2011 starring Michael Fassbender
    as a sex addict in New York City. We’ve all seen the research
    and the studies show that the power of prayer is magical no
    matter who or what it is that you think you’re praying to.
    Your sweetheart made a substantial show connected with dropping so that you can her joints and gasping prefer I’d
    virtually choked lifespan out of her.

  2. Talk to your child towards use of alcohol, drugs, and blazing.
    What is she doing to help me, a middle-class American housewife by overweight minor?

    A Whole Foods gift card fits to this idea too.

  3. Why Doesn’t Tim Murphy ANSWER any phone call, e-mails, DIRECTLY ??? He has someone call ( and usually the same person) who antagonizes the person who CAN”T get a hold of him personally. Why does a politician show up , wave to everyone in a rally and yet can’t EVEN TALK TO HIS PUBLIC?? What are you hiding from TIM?? Your to REPRESENT the publlic !
    You had your chance so step down and let another take over………..

  4. Tim Murphy has a good stance on issues for the people. The main strength that he has going for him is his staff that is present and represents him well in the public eye.
    The Tea Party and their canidates cannott hold a Candle to Murphy or his Staff.
    Great Men , have greater people behind them!

  5. The Tea Party and other conservatives are targeting the so called ‘moderate’ Republicans who vote with the Democrats. What good does it do to vote for a candidate who votes against your beliefs and interests?

  6. Is it me or does the Tea Party spend more time targeting Republicans than Democrats? With friends like these…who the heck needs enemies???

  7. Teabaggers love scab labor and paying someone as little as possible. Tim Murphy has been non partisan in some respects, the GOP wont be happy until they purge everyone with a moderate view point.

  • Reader Poll: Who Should the GOP Nominate for Governor?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...
Continue to Browser


To install tap and choose
Add to Home Screen