Close this search box.

WashPo’s “Mapping the Future” Redistricting Series Focuses on Pennsylvania

The most likely outcome of the GOP’s redistricting efforts in Pennsylvania appears to be combining the districts of Reps. Jason Altmire and Mark Critz, according to a Washington Post analysis published today.

The gambit makes sense, the Post’s Aaron Blake writes, because the Pittsburgh area from which Altmire and Critz hail has seen a more pronounced population loss than other parts of the state over the last decade.  Meanwhile, shifting Scranton to Rep. Tim Holden’s district will shore up the veteran Democrat’s hold on PA-17, but it will also give freshman Rep. Lou Barletta much needed breathing room in PA-11. 

“Republicans draw together Altmire’s 4th district and Critz’s 12th district by combining the incumbents’ homes in the northern Pittsburgh suburbs and Johnstown, respectively. Altmire’s district remains largely the same except for extending an arm out east to Johnstown. The rest of Critz’s district gets divided between three GOP districts — Rep. Glenn Thompson’s (R-Pa.) 5th district, Rep. Bill Shuster’s 9th (R-Pa.), and Rep. Tim Murphy’s (R-Pa.) 18th,” Blake writes.  His piece is the latest in the Post’s occasional series dissecting the redistricting process in key states.

The conflict as Blake casts it is whether the Keystone State GOP should focus on shoring up Barletta and his Republican colleagues from the Southeastern part of the state, or attempting to significantly weaken Altmire, Critz and Holden in one shot.  Veteran consultant Chris Nicholas, for one, was definitive: “There’s no reason why, at the federal level, we can’t do a lot of these things,” Nicholas said. “I reject the notion that you can only pick one.”

More from Blake’s analysis:

Pennsylvania Republicans got greedy a decade ago when they drew new congressional districts — and it came back to bite them as they watched a number of GOP-held seat go Democratic between 2002 and 2010.

The question is, will they be so aggressive again?

“Nobody has expressed any desire to get greedy,” said one Republican close to the state’s redistricting process. “2001 taught us a good lesson: You draw these districts marginally and you open yourself up to changing demographics.”

Click here to continue reading.

One Response

  1. Critz will not necessarily end up in Altmire’s district. He is just as likely to be in Mike Doyle’s Pittsburgh-based district. The Washington Post ignores the Republicans concern to hold on to Mike Kelly in the 3rd. He upset Kathy Dahlkemper in the NW PA district last year but his base is 75 miles from the population center of Erie. Republicans control the process and they can’t help Kelly without benefiting Altmire. Of the seven current Democrat Congress members from PA, Altmire is the least injurious to Republicans.

  • Reader Poll: Should President Joe Biden Step Aside?

    • Yes. He should step aside because of his age, declining ability to do the job. (45%)
    • No. He should not step aside. (39%)
    • Yes. He should step aside because he can't beat Donald Trump. (15%)

    Total Voters: 231

    Loading ... Loading ...
Continue to Browser


To install tap and choose
Add to Home Screen