Close this search box.

Murphy Leads Charge, Takes Lumps on Solyndra Issue

By Keegan Gibson, Managing Editor

Tim Murphy is getting some time in the sun. He’s been a leading voice in the investigation of Solyndra, a solar energy manufacturer in California that went bankrupt after receiving a federally-backed loan via the economic stimulus program. He’s also taking heat over his support of similar programs in the past.

He and other critics seized on the initial news, and have alleged that the White House had conflict of interest. This week, emails emerged in which the Energy Department requested Solyndra delay its layoffs until the day after the 2010 midterm elections.

Murphy (R-Allegheny) has been near or at the front of the story. He’s done dozens of interviews on the subject, including Fox News, CNN, CNBC and more.

In a Thursday morning hearing, members of Murphy’s House Energy and Commerce Committee questioned Energy Secretary Stephen Chu about the issues. Chu said the loan had been his call.

It’s been good press for Murphy. After all, what Republican congressman wouldn’t the chance to be a headache for the Obama administration?

But it’s not all sunshine for the Congressman. His critics – Democrats and Republicans alike – are calling hypocrisy, based on his own history of supporting federally-backed loans for alternative energy projects.

“Solyndra represents big government run amok, but Tim Murphy’s feigned outrage is mired with hypocrisy,” said Evan Feinberg, Murphy’s primary challenger. “Murphy voted for and enthusiastically supported the program authorizing this flawed intrusion into the energy sector.”

Several emails have gone out to reporters highlighting this highly unflattering profile in USA Today, which details Murphy’s support for Westinghouse Electric. The company, which is headquartered in Butler County, Pa., received $450 million in federal loan guarantees to build two nuclear power plants.

Westinghouse and its employees also account for $40,000 in campaign contributions to Murphy over the past decade.

On ideology, Murphy cedes the territory to his right. He is unapologetic in his support of federal assistance for alternative energy, citing the need to move the country away from foreign oil imports.

“It’s simply not the same as Solyndra,” said Murphy. “That was an economic stimulus issue that changed the rules, that I did not vote for. And the economic stimulus bill changed it so they didn’t have to come up with the money up front to cover some of the costs of the loan.”

Murphy supported the Energy Policy Act of 2005, which established similar guarantees for alternative energy production. But those guarantees are different from those in the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, aka the stimulus plan. According to, the stimulus changed the loan process to remove credit subsidy fees – which act as an insurance premium – against the possibility of default.

He denied a conflict of interest with Westinghouse, and blamed the White House for trying to muddy the waters. A source close to the Congressmen noted that the reporter who penned the USA Today piece has written similar stories on other Obama critics, including Sen. Orrin Hatch and Rep. Fred Upton.

“I make no apologies for supporting jobs in western Pennsylvania. Westinghouse has added thousands of jobs from the [Energy] Policy Act of 2005.”

5 Responses

  1. constantly a big enthusiast of linking to bloggers which i adore but don’t get lots of link love from.

  2. Tim Murphy is not “too liberal” for his district. The right dem (which there hasn’t been yet) would challenge Murphy and easily defeat an unknown in feinberg. Feinberg is pretty much irrelevant.

  3. Tim Murpy is a Solar Hypocrite

    He is taking advantage of the Solyndra solar panel scandal to promote his own now floundering campaign to keep his House seat at any cost.

    Tim Murphy has a long history of supporting government funding of uneconomic renewable energy projects such as solar energy. In fact, he recently authored and was the primary sponsor of H.R. 1861, the Infrastructure Jobs and Energy Independence Act. This bill rightly opens up our continental shelves for oil exploration but then spends the money generated on just the same type of subsidies for solar projects that he now rails against.

    His voting record over the last ten years shows that he has consistently supported uneconomic “green energy” subsidies similar to the Solyndra deal time after time. Why is Tim Murphy only now voicing concern? Maybe he is nearing a primary election and needs to pump up his conservative credentials.

    Tim Murphy is not a free market guy, he is using billions of dollars of subsidies targeted to uneconomic solar and wind to pick winners and losers.

  4. Evan Feinberg is the fiscal common sense, free market candidate in this contest. Tim Murphy is well-known for his support of Big Government Liberal programs, financed by The Forgotten Taxpayer.

    The Forgotten Taxpayer works,saves and invests to produce the goods and provide the services that raise our standard of living AND finances government.

    Evan Feinberg is The Forgotten Taxpayer’s BFF 🙂

    Faux Republican Tim Murphy is way too liberal for his district which is being punished by Big Government’s failed programs.

  • Reader Poll: Should President Joe Biden Step Aside?

    • Yes. He should step aside because of his age, declining ability to do the job. (45%)
    • No. He should not step aside. (39%)
    • Yes. He should step aside because he can't beat Donald Trump. (15%)

    Total Voters: 231

    Loading ... Loading ...
Continue to Browser


To install tap and choose
Add to Home Screen